The 2024-25 NBA MVP race has crystallized into one of the most compelling showdowns in recent memory, highlighting two extraordinary talents: Nikola Jokić and Shai Gilgeous-Alexander (SGA). The narrative is rich with contrasting styles, team dynamics, and critical endorsements—most notably from Michael Malone, Jokić’s former coach—who surprisingly threw weight behind Gilgeous-Alexander’s MVP credentials. This comprehensive analysis unpacks the key elements of this debate, exploring the players’ performances, coaching perspectives, fan and media sentiments, and the broader significance of this MVP contest.
Setting the Stage: The MVP Race Context
As the NBA inches towards the season’s climax, the MVP award—a recognition of the league’s most valuable player—has effectively boiled down to these two stars. Nikola Jokić, the Denver Nuggets’ cornerstone, continues to defy traditional position roles with his unique skill set as a center who orchestrates offense, scores prolifically, and impacts the game on multiple fronts. Shai Gilgeous-Alexander has evolved into the driving force behind the Oklahoma City Thunder’s surge, blending silky scoring with impressive leadership to transform a young roster into a Western Conference contender.
While Jokić has long been viewed as an MVP talent—having secured the award multiple times—the emergence of Gilgeous-Alexander as a genuine rival adds intrigue and uncertainty. This tension reflects a classic MVP conundrum: individual greatness versus team success, and traditional stats versus intangibles like leadership and clutch performances.
Michael Malone’s Unexpected MVP Endorsement
Michael Malone, who coached Jokić for several years and helped develop him into an MVP, recently raised eyebrows by openly praising Shai Gilgeous-Alexander as the MVP during the playoffs. Shortly after the Thunder’s decisive Game 1 victory over the Minnesota Timberwolves in the Western Conference finals, Malone remarked, “Shai showed why he’s the MVP,” a comment that reverberated across social media and sports media outlets.
This endorsement is layered with meaning. On one hand, Malone’s professed loyalty to Jokić is well-documented, as he has previously described watching Jokić play as witnessing greatness on a nightly basis. On the other hand, Malone’s acknowledgment of Gilgeous-Alexander’s MVP qualities suggests a recognition of the depth and nuance of this race—it’s no foregone conclusion but rather a legitimate contest.
Player Performance and Impact: Jokić vs. Gilgeous-Alexander
Nikola Jokić continues to put up staggering individual numbers, highlighted by mind-boggling performances such as a 61-point triple-double. His all-around influence—scoring, rebounding, passing, and defensive presence—creates a ripple effect that elevates the entire Nuggets squad. Jokić’s unique basketball IQ and versatility make him a one-man orchestra capable of controlling games in ways few players can.
Shai Gilgeous-Alexander, meanwhile, stands as a sleek, dynamic guard whose scoring prowess and offensive creativity have powered the Thunder into serious playoff contention. Unlike Jokić’s well-established MVP pedigree, SGA’s rise represents the blossoming of a new superstar. His ability to carry a young and relatively inexperienced team speaks volumes about his value. It’s a narrative of emergent leadership combined with elite skill execution.
Comparing the two on paper yields nuanced arguments: Jokić’s raw stats and effect on team efficiency often outshine SGA’s, but Gilgeous-Alexander’s contribution to team success, often in clutch moments, provides a persuasive case from a winning perspective. Social media and fan debates often echo this divide, with some valuing “doing more” (Jokić) versus “winning more” (SGA).
Coaching and Tactical Perspectives
Malone’s comments underscore the layered coaching angles present in this MVP conversation. As Jokić’s former coach, Malone naturally defends the player he helped mold, yet his candid praise of SGA suggest an appreciation of the young star’s skill and impact. Nuggets’ current coaching approach continues to highlight Jokić’s strengths, while the Thunder’s system maximizes Gilgeous-Alexander’s agility and scoring.
There’s also tactical awareness in Malone’s remarks: endorsing SGA can be seen as promoting the league’s evolution, recognizing a guard’s emergent dominance in a league that balances offense and defense differently than in prior eras.
Fan Reactions and Media Narratives
The MVP debate ignites passionate discussion among fans and analysts. Social media buzz reflects a divided camp—some enraged by Malone’s seeming shift from Jokić to SGA, others celebrating it as validation of Gilgeous-Alexander’s rise. Twitter storms, memes, and hot takes continuously fuel the fire.
Media outlets often highlight the razor-thin margins between the two candidates as the defining storyline of the 2024-25 season. The presence of other contenders like Giannis Antetokounmpo adds context but often plays a supporting role in the broader duel.
Team Success and MVP Criteria
The MVP often hinges on how a player’s individual greatness translates to team achievements. Here, Shai Gilgeous-Alexander receives an edge because the Thunder have surged to one of the West’s top seeds, driven by his leadership. Meanwhile, the Nuggets are also performing strongly, but each team’s distinct style and roster composition invite debate on whose efforts are more “valuable.”
This decision-making facet encompasses more than statistics; it encapsulates narratives, clutch moments, defensive contributions, and intangibles like inspiring teammates.
Conclusion: A Race for the Ages
The 2024-25 NBA MVP race between Nikola Jokić and Shai Gilgeous-Alexander exemplifies the complexities in measuring “value” in professional basketball. It’s a contest that blends statistical brilliance with team impact, legacy with breakout performance, and tradition with innovation. Michael Malone’s unexpected praise of Gilgeous-Alexander adds an intriguing twist, emphasizing that the MVP honor is ever-evolving and that greatness can be recognized from multiple perspectives.
Ultimately, this race is a testament to the depth of talent in the NBA today, offering fans an electrifying spectacle and a reminder that basketball excellence wears many faces. Whether the trophy ends up with Jokić or Gilgeous-Alexander, this chapter of the NBA’s history will be remembered for the thrilling debate it inspired and the outstanding basketball it showcased.
—
Dive into the MVP debate as fiercely as Giannis and Malone do—stay ahead with expert NBA insights at Learn more
