The Downfall of Lorne Donaldson: A Detailed Analysis of the Chicago Stars’ Coaching Shakeup
The Chicago Stars’ decision to part ways with head coach Lorne Donaldson after a dismal start to the 2025 National Women’s Soccer League (NWSL) season has sent shockwaves through the soccer community. This move, coming just six games into the season, raises several questions about the team’s direction, the effectiveness of Donaldson’s strategies, and the future of the franchise. This report delves into the circumstances surrounding Donaldson’s dismissal, the team’s performance under his tenure, and the potential implications for the Chicago Stars moving forward.
The Rise and Fall of Lorne Donaldson
Lorne Donaldson’s journey with the Chicago Stars began in 2024, following a successful stint with the Jamaica national team. His appointment was part of a broader overhaul by the new ownership, aiming to revitalize the franchise. Donaldson’s tenure started promisingly, with the Stars securing a playoff spot in his first season, finishing with a 10-14-2 record. However, the 2025 season has been a stark contrast, with the team languishing at the bottom of the NWSL standings after a 1-5 start.
A Season of Struggles
The 2025 season has been marred by several challenges for the Chicago Stars. The abrupt absence of USWNT star Mallory Swanson due to unspecified personal reasons has undoubtedly impacted the team’s performance. Swanson’s absence has left a void in the team’s attacking prowess, making it difficult for the Stars to find the back of the net consistently. Additionally, the team’s defensive struggles have been evident, with the Stars conceding goals at a high rate.
The Decision to Fire Donaldson
The decision to fire Donaldson was not made lightly. General manager Richard Feuz acknowledged the coach’s contributions to the team’s culture and sense of self-belief. However, the team’s poor performance and the need for immediate results likely played a significant role in the decision. The Stars’ lone win this season came in a 2-1 victory over Bay FC on April 13, a glimmer of hope in an otherwise disappointing campaign.
The Interim Solution
With Donaldson’s departure, first assistant coach Masaki Hemmi has been appointed as the interim head coach. Hemmi, who will work closely with assistant coaches Ella Masar and Karina Báez, faces a daunting task. The team’s next game, against an as-yet-unannounced opponent, will be a critical test of Hemmi’s leadership and the team’s ability to turn around their fortunes.
The Broader Context
The Chicago Stars’ decision to fire Donaldson is not an isolated incident. The franchise has a history of coaching changes, with previous head coaches Chris Petrucelli and Rory Dames also being dismissed amid struggles. This pattern of instability raises questions about the club’s long-term strategy and its ability to build a sustainable winning culture.
The Future of the Chicago Stars
As the Chicago Stars look to the future, several key factors will determine their success. The team must address its defensive vulnerabilities and find a consistent goal-scoring threat. The search for a permanent head coach will be crucial, with the club needing someone who can instill a winning mentality and build on the foundations laid by Donaldson.
Conclusion: A Crossroads for the Chicago Stars
The firing of Lorne Donaldson marks a pivotal moment for the Chicago Stars. The team stands at a crossroads, with the potential to either rebuild and rise from the ashes or continue to flounder in mediocrity. The interim tenure of Masaki Hemmi will be a critical period, providing a glimpse into the team’s potential under new leadership. As the Stars search for a permanent head coach, they must prioritize stability and a clear vision for the future. The coming weeks and months will be crucial in shaping the franchise’s trajectory and determining whether they can overcome their current struggles and return to competitiveness in the NWSL.
