The Standoff in Cincinnati: Shemar Stewart’s Contract Dispute with the Bengals
The Cincinnati Bengals are facing an early test with their first-round draft pick, Shemar Stewart. Selected as the 17th overall pick in the 2025 NFL Draft out of Texas A&M, the defensive end is currently embroiled in a contract dispute with the team, preventing him from participating in any on-field work since being drafted. This standoff has escalated, becoming a very public battle, with Stewart expressing his disappointment and determination not to practice until his contract demands are met.
The Heart of the Matter: Contract Language
At the core of the dispute is a specific detail in the contract language. Stewart is reportedly requesting that his contract mirror the language of the Bengals’ previous two first-round picks, both selected after pick No. 17. While the exact nature of this language remains somewhat shrouded in mystery, it is believed to involve certain protections or guarantees related to participation agreements and potential injury clauses. One report suggested the Bengals offered a percentage related to training camp roster bonuses that fell short of what the 17th pick received in 2024. Stewart himself has stated that he’s “not asking for nothing y’all have never done before,” implying the requested language is consistent with past Bengals’ deals or standard practices in the league.
Stewart’s Stance: Unwavering and Public
Stewart has taken a firm stance, refusing to practice until the contractual issues are resolved. He expressed frustration with how the Bengals are handling the situation, emphasizing that he believes he is “100 percent right” and that the team needs to “get it done.” He stated he wants to practice “very bad” but will not compromise until he signs the contract. This holdout has led to Stewart missing rookie minicamp and other valuable offseason workout programs. He has been present at the team’s facilities, attending meetings and observing practice sessions; however, he remains on the sidelines.
The Bengals’ Perspective: Unclear
While Stewart has been vocal about his demands, the Bengals’ perspective on the contract negotiations remains less clear. The team has not issued any official statements addressing the specifics of the dispute. This silence has fueled speculation and frustration among fans, and has led some to accuse the team of “bungling” the negotiations. Some observers have suggested that the Bengals are hesitant to set a precedent with Stewart’s contract, potentially impacting future negotiations with other draft picks. Others believe it may come down to the team and player having different risk tolerances.
The Cost of the Stalemate: Lost Development Time
The longer this contract dispute drags on, the more both sides stand to lose, especially Stewart who needs reps. The Bengals are missing out on the opportunity to integrate Stewart into their defensive scheme and develop him into a key player for the 2025 season. Every practice Stewart misses is a missed opportunity for him to learn the playbook, build rapport with his teammates, and hone his skills under the guidance of the coaching staff. Some observers have pointed out the parallel with the Bengals’ failure to get Ja’Marr Chase ready for the start of the 2024 season, highlighting the importance of a fully prepared rookie.
The Fan Reaction: A Mixed Bag
Fan reaction to the contract dispute has been mixed. Some fans support Stewart’s stance, arguing that he is justified in demanding fair contract terms and protecting his future. Others are frustrated with the holdout, viewing it as a distraction and a potential setback for the team. This has created division within the Bengals fanbase, with some questioning Stewart’s commitment and others criticizing the team’s handling of the situation. Despite the disagreement, most fans agree that it is crucial for both sides to reach a resolution as quickly as possible to avoid further damage.
Parallels to Past Disputes: Lessons Learned?
The Bengals have had their share of contract-related issues with high-profile players in the past. Some observers have drawn parallels to these previous disputes, suggesting the team should have learned from those experiences and taken a more proactive approach in negotiating with Stewart. However, the details of each situation vary, and it is difficult to draw definitive conclusions about the Bengals’ handling of the current dispute.
The Road Ahead: Finding Common Ground
The key to resolving this contract standoff lies in both sides finding common ground. Stewart needs to be willing to negotiate and possibly compromise on certain aspects of his demands. The Bengals need to demonstrate flexibility and a willingness to address Stewart’s concerns, even if it means deviating slightly from their standard contract practices. Injury protection for draft picks and players is often discussed amongst fans and provides stability. The clock is ticking, and the Bengals and Stewart need to be proactive.
A Call for a Swift Resolution
The Shemar Stewart contract dispute is more than just a negotiation; it is a test of the Cincinnati Bengals’ commitment to their players and their ability to build a winning team. A swift and equitable resolution is in the best interest of both sides, allowing Stewart to focus on his development and the Bengals to maximize their investment in a promising young talent. The question remains: can the Bengals and Stewart bridge the gap and forge a path forward that benefits both player and team, or will this standoff cast a long shadow over the start of Stewart’s NFL career? Ultimately, the outcome of this negotiation will not only impact Stewart’s future but also signal the Bengals’ approach to player relations and team building in the years to come.
